← All posts Blog · Strategy

How to choose a lead generation agency: 12 questions to ask

For founders and sales heads shortlisting outbound agencies. Twelve questions that separate agencies that will deliver from those that will not, and what a good answer sounds like.

Short answer

To choose a lead generation agency, ask how it will research your market before quoting, how many leads it will contact and from what infrastructure, how it defines a qualified meeting, and what it reports. The biggest red flag is a price or a meeting guarantee given before any research.

How do you choose the right lead generation agency?

By testing how it thinks before you test what it sends. When founders tell us about agencies that did not deliver, the pattern is almost always the same: nobody researched the market first. The agency quoted a price, promised meetings and started sending.

The twelve questions below show you whether an agency has a method or a template.

What should you ask about research and targeting?

  1. How many companies fit my market, and how did you work that out? A good answer includes a number and the sources behind it.
  2. How will you build the list? Look for several sources and manual checks, not one database export. See where Apollo falls short for India.
  3. Who exactly will you contact? Roles, seniority and why.
  4. Will you show me the plan before I pay? It should cover the number of companies, people reached, how and with what offer.

What should you ask about infrastructure and deliverability?

  1. Will you send from my main domain? The answer should be no.
  2. How many mailboxes and domains, and how many emails per mailbox a day? Compare with safe sending limits.
  3. How do you verify emails and test inbox placement? Expect verification with catch-alls removed and regular placement tests. See our deliverability checklist.
  4. How do you handle opt outs and data rules? See is cold email legal in India.

What should you ask about results and pricing?

  1. What counts as a qualified meeting? Get it in writing.
  2. What will you report each week? Replies, positive replies and meetings.
  3. What is in the fee, and what is billed on top? See pay per meeting vs retainer.
  4. Can I see results from a market like mine, with real numbers? Logos alone are not proof.

What do good and bad answers sound like?

QuestionGood answerRed flag
How many meetings will I get?"Let us size your market first, then we will show the maths."A guaranteed number on the first call
Where do leads come from?Several sources, verified per campaign"We have a database of millions"
Which domain do you send from?Separate, warmed up sending domainsYour main domain
What do you report?Replies, positive replies, meetingsEmails sent and open rates
Who writes the emails?Someone senior, per buyer groupOne template for every client
What if it does not work?A clear exitA long lock-in

From our campaigns: a number to check any promise against

From our campaigns

Across the campaigns where we tracked meetings, it took about 190 to 340 leads contacted to produce one meeting. If an agency promises 30 meetings a month, ask how many leads it will contact. Fewer than about 5,700 would mean it expects far better rates than we have seen across 70,000+ leads. The data is in our reply rate benchmarks.

Before we quote, we research the market and lay out the plan in writing: how many companies fit, how many people we will reach, how, and with what offer. Only then do we price it. Ask every agency on your shortlist to do the same.

How should you compare shortlisted agencies?

Put their written plans side by side. The best plan is rarely the cheapest or the one with the biggest promise. It is the one that shows the agency understands who your buyers are and how hard they are to reach. Our case studies show the kind of proof to ask for, and our agency vs SDR comparison covers the hiring alternative.

You are welcome to ask us all twelve. If you want a view of costs first, read how much a cold email agency costs in India. For a worked example of the proof to expect, see the decor manufacturer case study.

About the author

Aashir Kalam is the co-founder of Emporia, a done-for-you cold email agency in Delhi NCR that has sent over 1 million cold emails and booked 1,000+ meetings for B2B companies. He writes these posts from live campaign data.

Common questions

What is the biggest red flag in a lead generation agency?
A price or a guaranteed number of meetings before the agency has researched your market. Without research, both are guesses.
Should a lead generation agency guarantee meetings?
Be careful. Guarantees given before research often lead to low quality meetings booked to hit a number.
What should a lead generation agency report?
Replies, positive replies and meetings each week. Emails sent and open rates say little about results.
How many leads should an agency contact per meeting?
In our campaigns it took about 190 to 340 leads per meeting, so use that to sanity check promises.
What proof should I ask an agency for?
Case studies with real numbers from markets like yours, and a written plan for your campaign before you pay.
Ask us all 12. We are happy to answer them on a call. Book a call